Call a licensed agent: 833-964-9663

Am I paying too much for car insurance? 

Written by Elizabeth Rivelli

Reviewed by Alyssa DiCrasto

Last updated: January 6, 2023

Almost 60% of drivers believe they’re paying too much for auto insurance, according to a survey from Forbes Advisor. But how do you know if you’re paying too much for car insurance? 

When you apply for a car insurance policy, the insurer looks at many different factors to determine your premium. Rates are personalized based on your location, age, credit score, and driving record, among other things. To figure out if you’re paying the lowest rate possible, it’s important to shop around and compare rates from multiple companies. 

In this guide, we’ll help you understand whether your auto insurance premium is too high and share some tips that may help you stop overpaying for car insurance. 

Am I paying too much for car insurance?

Many drivers have asked themselves, “Am I paying too much for car insurance?” After all, car insurance can be very expensive, especially if you have a poor credit score or a history of accidents or insurance claims. 

However, it can be difficult to determine whether your car insurance rate is appropriate for your personal situation. Rates are personalized to each driver, and insurance companies use special algorithms and formulas to set your rate. You may find that one insurance company charges much higher rates for the same types and amounts of coverage than another. 

Ultimately, the only way to find out if you’re paying too much for car insurance is to get new quotes from other car insurance companies. If a different insurer can offer you a cheaper rate for the same coverages, you’re probably paying too much for auto insurance.

Compare car insurance near you

"*" indicates required fields

Zip Code*

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Why is my car insurance so high?

If you’re wondering why your insurance so high, it could be because of a variety of factors. Here are some of the most common things that contribute to expensive car insurance premiums: 

  • Location: If you live in an area with a high risk of severe weather, like hurricanes, or an area with a high crime rate, you could pay more for auto insurance.  

  • Age: Young drivers who are newly licensed typically pay the highest car insurance rates. Premiums start to decrease as you get older.  

  • Gender: In general, males pay slightly higher car insurance rates than women.  

  • Credit score: Drivers with excellent credit scores are viewed as less risky, and often pay lower rates for auto insurance than drivers with poor credit.  

  • Driving record: If you have any recent traffic violations on your record, like an at-fault accident, speeding ticket, or DUI, you can expect to pay a higher rate for car insurance. After these violations are removed from your record, your premium should return to its previous level. 
  • Vehicle make and model: Your vehicle’s make and model can have an impact on the cost of your policy. New cars tend to be more expensive to insure than used models. If your car has a salvage or rebuilt title, that can also impact your premium.  

  • Policy details: The type and amount of coverage you want, as well as your deductibles, will impact the cost of your car insurance policy.  

How can I lower my car insurance premiums?

If you think you’re paying too much for car insurance, there are many ways to potentially lower your premium. Here are several ways to save money on your auto insurance policy: 

  • Look for discounts: Most car insurance providers offer discounts to help drivers save money on their policies. While every insurer offers different discounts, you can often find savings for smart students, safe drivers, having certain safety features in your vehicle, taking a defensive driving course, and bundling two or more policies. 
  • Raise your deductibles: Some policies, like collision and comprehensive insurance, have a deductible, which gets subtracted from your payout when you have a claim. Raising your deductible will lower your monthly premium. However, before raising it, make sure you can afford to pay a higher deductible out-of-pocket should you ever need to make a claim. 

  • Review your coverages: If you haven’t reviewed your car insurance policy in a while, you might have coverages you no longer need. Check your policy to see if you can drop coverages or lower your policy limits to save money. 

  • Pay your premium in full: Most car insurance providers will give you a small discount on your policy if you pay your annual premium upfront and in full. 

  • Improve your credit score: Drivers with good credit generally pay lower rates for car insurance than drivers with poor credit. To save money on your auto insurance policy, work on improving your credit. 

  • Shop around: It’s a good idea to shop around and get quotes from a few different insurance companies. That’s the most effective way to find the cheapest car insurance premium for your situation. Get new quotes once per year, after a claim, or after a major life event, like adding a teen driver to your policy.  

Compare top insurance providers to find the right policy at the right price

Personalized results. No phone number or email required.

"*" indicates required fields

Zip Code*

How can I switch car insurance providers?

If you find a cheaper car insurance policy from another provider, you should consider switching companies. You can typically switch car insurance companies at any time, even in the middle of your policy period. However, it’s a good idea to contact your current car insurance company to ask about potential cancellation fees you might have to pay. 

The process of switching car insurance companies is usually pretty easy. Purchase the new policy first, then contact your current provider and let them know you’d like to cancel. Buying a new policy first ensures you won’t have a gap in coverage between your new policy’s start date and the old policy’s end date. 

Learn more about switching car insurance companies >

How do I know if I am overpaying for car insurance?

To answer the question, “Am I overpaying for car insurance,” you should compare auto insurance quotes from several different companies. That way, you can easily see which company can offer you the lowest rate for your situation and the type of coverage you want.  

To simplify the process, you can use Rate Retriever to compare car insurance. Fill out the online questionnaire and get matched with top-rated companies in your area.  

About Rate Retriever

At Rate Retriever, our mission is to make the way you shop for insurance transparent and fair through user-friendly tools that respect your privacy and deliver reliable, comprehensive results 

So we took everything we hated about comparing insurance quotes online – the spam, the long questionnaires, the limited choices, the inaccuracy of quote prices – and threw it out the window, favoring a short form that more accurately estimates what you’ll pay at each of the top insurance providers near you. 

Rate Retriever is an independent company that is not owned by an insurance provider, nor do we provide insurance ourselves. This independence allows us to be your free and impartial insurance research tool, helping you make the best decisions for your insurance needs.  

We may earn a commission when you click one of the links or call one of the providers listed on our site; however, we do not allow our partnerships to influence which information we provide. 

Share this article